The nominees for Best Director, 1931-32, had all been here before. Josef von Sternberg had just been nominated the previous year for Morocco, when he lost to Skippy's Norman Taurog. King Vidor was on his third go-round, having been previously nominated at the Third Academy Awards for the all-Black musical Hallelujah, which he lost to Lewis Milestone for All Quiet on the Western Front, and at the First Academy Awards, where he was nominated for The Crowd. The man he lost to, the first-ever winner for Best Director, was none other than Frank Borzage, nominated then for Seventh Heaven.
And now we have Borzage on his second nomination, for Bad Girl. And guess what? He won again! Two for two? Not so bad, Mr. Borzage. But let's take a closer look, shall we?
second and final nomination, past winner
As I mentioned before, I barely remember the movie, but I do remember it being beautifully shot, sometimes unexpectedly so: the scenes in the walk-up, the will-they-won't-they apartment scene where lights keep going off and the unmarrieds aren't leaving...the staging of the theatre, the intimacy of cinema! The momentum of the opening 30 minutes are wonderful.
third of five nominations
Vidor's empathy for imperfect people and their imperfect decisions are what give The Champ its humanity, facing tragedy without becoming overwrought. Even in Jackie Cooper's film-ending sob scene, where he wanders from person to person crying uncontrollably for what feels like 45 seconds with Vidor's camera in his face. It's not so much grotesque manipulation of emotions than it is allowing someone to bare their pain openly, as unconsolable as he may be, as helpless as we may feel in the moment. It's a moment earned by the work Vidor has done in believably presenting these people's lives, the very real connection between father and son. I can't get over how honest this movie is.
Josef von Sternberg
second and final nomination
Of all this year's nominees in any category, out of all the movies I've seen, Josef von Sternberg and Shanghai Express have been the greatest challenge to write about. He does not bother with realism, yet the emotions ring truer than other films. He is dealing with stock characters - evil Chinese, mysterious corrupted Euro babe, haughty Englishwoman, gruff American - yet they all possess a complexity of moral character rarely seen. It's very much a movie, one that entrances, enchants, one that feels tense and dangerous and sexy. That's all Von Sternberg.
Borzage won the second of his two Oscars here. My vote goes to:
JOSEF VON STERNBERG
Tomorrow, the nominees for Best Actor: Wallace Beery (The Champ), Alfred Lunt (The Guardsman), Fredric March (Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde).